http://www.defence.lk/new.asp?fname=sri_lanka_has_many_challenges_face_and_many_opportunities_exploit_says_secretary_Defence_20120320_02
Sri Lanka has many challenges to face and many opportunities to exploit" says
Secretary Defence
"As a country emerging from the shadows of terrorism into a
bright, prosperous future, Sri Lanka has many challenges to face and many
opportunities to exploit", stated Secretary Ministry of Defence and Urban
Development Mr. Gotabaya Rajapaksa.
He expressed these views today (March 20), delivering the
keynote address as Chief Guest at the inauguration ceremony of the World Bank
initiated High -Level Policy Workshop at the Cinnamon Grand, Hotel in Colombo.
The two day workshop for professionals and policy makers under the South Asia
Region Urbanization Knowledge Platform, concentrated on 'Sustainable Urban
Regeneration and Inclusive Growth for South Asian Cities'.
"The Government has a clear intention to upgrade the quality of
life of the people in slums and shanties by providing them proper housing
facilities. It is not only important to give them much higher quality places to
live in, but also to facilitate a better quality of community life for them",
Mr. Gotabaya Rajapaksa further asserted in his speech on the 'Challenges of
Urban Development from a Sri Lankan Perspective'.
Mr. Ming Zhang, Sector Manager, Urban, Water and Disaster Risk
Management, South Asia, World Bank, Guest of Honour, Jesse Robredo, Secretary,
Department of Interior and Local Government, Philippines and Ms. Abha
Joshi-Ghani, Sector Manager, Finance Economics and Urban Development, Urban
Unit, World Bank were also the distinguished speakers of the morning secession
at the event.
Mayor of the Colombo Municipal Council Mr. A.J.M Muzammil was
also present at the occasion.
Full text of the speech delivered by Secretary to the
Ministry of Defence and Urban Development at the 'South Asia Region Urbanization
Knowledge Platform', on 20th March, 2012.
"The Challenges of Urban Development
from a Sri Lankan Perspective" Keynote Speech at the Launch of the World Bank's
South Asia Region Urbanisation Knowledge Platform
Guest of Honour, Mr. Jesse Robredo, Secretary, Department of
Interior and Local Government, Government of the Philippines
Ms. Abha Joshi-Ghani, World Bank Sector Manager: Finance,
Economic & Urban Development Department
Mr. Ming Zhang, World Bank Sector Manager for South Asia Urban
Development
Mr. Greg Clark, Global City Advisor and Chairman, British
Business Improvement Districts
Ladies and Gentlemen,
I thank World Bank for having invited me to be the Chief Guest
at the Launch of the South Asia Region Urbanisation Knowledge Platform. I hope
that the sharing of knowledge that will take place through this Platform will be
to the great benefit of all the nations represented here. On behalf of the
Government, I take this opportunity to warmly welcome all of you to Sri Lanka.
It is a pleasure and an honour for us to have so distinguished a group of
international urban experts and decision makers in Sri Lanka for this event.
Less than three years ago, Sri Lanka emerged from the shadow of
a terrorist conflict that had lasted for nearly thirty years. Quite apart from
the lives lost and the affect that this conflict had on our society, its impact
on our economic development was tremendous. Now that we have achieved peace, a
rapid economic growth is taking place after many years of stagnation. Because of
the peace, stability and freedom now enjoyed throughout Sri Lanka, investors are
very confident about this county's prospects. They are showing a keen interest
to tap the great potential available in this country in many sectors. Tourists,
too, are returning to Sri Lanka in large numbers. The Government is confident
that these are healthy signs of even greater things to come.
With the on-going economic growth, a great deal of urban
regeneration is very clearly taking place in Sri Lanka. This regeneration is
taking place in the capital city of Colombo, as well as in the other cities and
towns around the country. The development of Colombo is particularly important.
Known as a gateway to Sri Lanka since ancient times, it was a centre of activity
for successive colonial administrations in past centuries and is now the
country's largest, most vibrant and most modern city. Although other cities such
as Kandy, Galle, Jaffna and the fast emerging city of Hambantota also play
important roles in the life of this nation, uplifting Colombo to a world-class
city remains a key priority of the Government.
With its rapid growth over the centuries, the urban development
of Colombo poses a diverse set of challenges. A very significant issue facing
Colombo is the large number of people who live in underserved settlements
throughout the city. During the past few decades, many people migrated to
Colombo from all around the country. A large number of them were seeking to
escape the terrorist conflict in the North and East. Others were mostly poor
people from the rural areas, attracted to Colombo because of the economic
activity and good prospects in the city.
As they lacked the wealth for proper housing facilities, most of
these people settled in poorly constructed shanties and slums that sprawl over
the cityscape. These settlements are mostly on government lands in various parts
of Colombo. Many of them are on the reservations set aside around the lakes,
canals, roadways and railway tracks. These settlements lack basic facilities and
sanitation. The hygiene of the people living in them is poor. Their living
conditions are bad, criminal activity is rife and they and their children
undergo various hardships on a daily basis. Their quality of life leaves much to
be desired. Finding a solution to this issue is one of the key challenges before
the Government.
Improving and redeveloping the infrastructure of city areas also
poses a serious challenge for urban development in Sri Lanka. The drainage
system and flood control systems require rapid improvements. A sewerage system
is present only in the city limits, and it is quite overburdened. There are also
other infrastructure related problems that impede the uplifting of living
standards. The limited space available for public spaces such as parks and other
recreational spaces has long been a serious issue. The Government is keen to
ensure that appropriate remedies are found for this problem, as access to public
spaces is a significant factor in the quality of life of all citizens.
Another significant challenge is the number of unauthorised
small boutiques that have been set up mainly on pavements, roads and
reservations in various parts of the city. These boutiques reduce space
available to commuters and prevent the expansion of roads by blocking the
reservations. A lot of problems regarding the cleaning and maintenance of roads
also arises due to the presence of these pavement hawkers. Because the people
who run these small boutiques depend on commuters en route to bus stations or
train stations for business, attempts to relocate them to other areas deprives
them of their income. We need to find a proper mechanism to enable them to
retain their livelihoods, whilst relocating them so that they no longer obstruct
pavements and roads and the proper maintenance of the city streets.
Colombo and the other cities in Sri Lanka also face very serious
difficulties regarding the management of solid waste. Garbage is typically
dumped in low-lying areas. This can have many serious consequences, including
the pollution of water and other environmental hazards for people in surrounding
areas. This is another area in which I hope fruitful discussions can take place
at this Platform, with particular emphasis on the solutions that have been
arrived at in other countries.
I believe that all of the challenges I discussed are significant
issues not only in Sri Lanka but also in the rest of the region. I hope that the
urban specialists from the World Bank and the various countries represented here
will be able to share with us their experiences and knowledge on these problems,
and discuss the ways in which these problems have been solved in other parts of
the world. As Sri Lanka moves forward into a brighter future, finding solutions
to these various issues is a high priority. The Government of Sri Lanka also
welcomes, and would greatly appreciate, any proposals of solutions for these
issues from the experts present and the institutions represented here.
At the same time, I would like to take this opportunity to
discuss with you some of the initiatives Sri Lanka has taken with regard to
urban development over the past few years. A significant programme that has been
undertaken is the rationalisation of the city of Colombo. Thirty years ago, a
city plan was developed that featured moving all government buildings and
offices out of Colombo to the adjacent administrative capital of Sri
Jayawardenepura, Kotte. A proposal was also made to develop that the
neighbouring region of Malabe as an education hub.
Over the past two years, moving the administrative buildings
from the Colombo city limits has been expedited. The construction of new office
buildings for the Government Ministries, Departments and offices at Sethsiripaya
in Battaramulla is rapidly underway. Stage II of the Sethsiripaya Complex is
nearing completion and is scheduled to open next month. Stage III of the complex
will be constructed as a Public Private Partnership. Several standalone
administrative complexes are also being created. The opening ceremony of the new
building for the Auditor General's Department took place yesterday. New
buildings will also be provided to the Department of Census & Statistics,
and the Registrar General's Department outside Colombo city limits.
Another key project being undertaken is the establishment of a
central Defence Headquarters Complex, which will house the headquarters of the
Army, Navy, Air Force as well as the Ministry of Defence. The work has already
started, and the land that was occupied by the Army headquarters near Galle Face
has been released to flagship investors for luxury hotel developments. Shangri
La Hotels and Resorts, one of the world's leading high-end hotel chains, has
already been allotted ten acres of land to establish a luxury hotel in that
location. ITC of India has signed an agreement to obtain the remainder of the
land to establish another luxury hotel. In addition to relocating Armed Forces
headquarters, a new Police Headquarters will also be constructed outside the
city.
To further rationalise space utilisation in the city, the
relocation of wholesale markets and other economic infrastructure to custom
designed locations outside the city limits is taking place. The old St. John's
fish market in Fort, which was the key wholesale market for fish in the Western
Province, has been shifted to Paliyagoda. The Manning market, which is the
wholesale market for vegetables, is also to be shifted to the same area.
Peliyagoda is poised to be a central location for the entire western province
with the construction of an Outer Circular Road. By using this road, heavy
vehicles that transport goods from these wholesale markets to retailers will be
able to avoid entering the city limits unless so required. By creating rail
links between the Colombo port and a container terminal and dry port being set
up at Paliyagoda, it will also become possible to drastically reduce container
traffic entering Colombo.
With regard to the underserved settlements, the Government has a
clear intention to upgrade the quality of life of the people in slums and
shanties by providing them proper housing facilities. It is not only important
to give them much higher quality places to live in, but also to facilitate a
better quality of community life for them. Under the Resettlement of Underserved
Settlements Project being undertaken by the Urban Development Authority, some
70,000 families living in poor conditions in Colombo will be given housing in
high rise buildings designed and constructed to a good standard. These buildings
will come up in close proximity to the original homes of these families, so that
they do not need to find different jobs or send their children to different
schools. The construction of 10,000 housing units is presently under way, and
plans are in place to expand this number by a further 15,000 during the next
year.
In this context, however, I have to note that providing proper
housing for the underserved settlements is a significant problem for town
planners and architects. Over the years, various administrations have tried to
tackle this issue, but they have had limited success. It has been observed that
relocating the urban poor to high-rise buildings causes several problems. The
people find it very difficult to adjust to their new environment. They typically
lack an interest in preserving these buildings properly, and their attention to
cleanliness is not as great as it should be. Because they are from the
low-income segment of society, they would find it difficult to maintain the
high-rise buildings properly even if they had an interest in doing so. As a
result, the cost of maintaining these buildings ultimately devolves onto the
government. With the initial construction cost of these buildings also being
very high, this makes relocating low-income segments to high-rise buildings is a
very costly exercise.
However, because the shantytowns and slums tend to be low-rise
buildings sprawled over large extents of land, one of the great benefits of the
relocation programme is that it will release a lot of prime land in Colombo for
commercial and other developments, including the creation of more public spaces.
Nevertheless, finding a more practical and end-user friendly solution to the
problem of underserved settlements is a high priority. The solutions identified
can be used for future projects to provide better housing to the people in the
underserved settlements.
An interesting programme of a somewhat different nature to the
resettlement of underserved settlements is underway in the Slave Island area.
This is the regeneration of urban spaces through Private Public Partnerships
with the cooperation of landowners. There are a large number of small private
homes and properties in this area that are old and quite run down. They need to
be replaced to enable the uplifting of the entire neighbourhood. Under a project
facilitated by the Urban Development Authority, regionally recognised players in
the property sector have undertaken to put up mixed developments with full
cooperation of the property owners. The householders will be resettled in high
quality high-rise accommodation within the same neighbourhood. It should be
noted that the problems typically facing high-rise apartment solutions to the
low-income settlement are unlikely to arise in this instance, since the people
who will reside in them will be better able to afford the cost of maintaining
the buildings.
The problem of flood prevention is another area of great concern
for the Government. This problem was caused as a result of the increase in
Colombo's population over the years. As the housing stock expanded, low-lying
areas and marshland were filled for construction purposes. This seriously
reduced the catchment areas available for water retention, and construction
related activities also often obstructed the canals and waterways critical for
drainage. As a result, the monsoonal rains can cause significant flooding in
Colombo. Solving this problem requires a number of different initiatives.
One solution presently being implemented is the dredging of
lakes to create water retention tanks in the upper catchment and lower catchment
zones of the Kotte area. Further, under a programme to be funded by the World
Bank, the drainage infrastructure of the city will be greatly strengthened.
Under this Metro Colombo Urban Development Project, the historic Beire lake will
be renovated. The lake was developed as the centrepiece of Colombo's drainage
mechanism by the Dutch more than two hundred years ago. However, it has been
largely neglected for many years. In the recent past, steps were taken to clean
its canals as an urgent response to the growing flood problem. Under the new
programme, the entire lake will be dredged and its floodgates will be repaired.
The creation of micro drainage systems and the creation of linear parks around
degraded wetlands, together with improvements to existing canals and lakes have
also been identified as important initiatives. In addition, institutional
strengthening of the agencies responsible for the city's drainage and public
infrastructure will be undertaken through this project. This will help enable
better long-term management of these issues.
While meeting all these development challenges, the Government
has been very much aware of the need to capitalise on the natural advantages
that historic cities like Colombo have. The unique blend of cultures and the
shared heritage of the various communities of this country must be highlighted
in its urban growth. There are old Colonial buildings all around Colombo and the
other cities of Sri Lanka. There are also ancient temples, kovils, mosques and
churches. There are public places with history and great symbolic value, such as
the Viharamahadevi park, or old Victoria park, and Independence Square. In
developing the city spaces, it is important to highlight this heritage. A number
of projects that have got underway in the recent past that have been
instrumental in doing so.
The recent renovation and reopening of the long neglected old
Dutch Hospital has been a tremendous success. While retaining the spirit of the
original architecture, a lot of value addition has taken place through the
transformation of the old hospital to a public open space housing high-end
shopping and restaurant facilities. The demand from the private sector for
similar spaces is very high. With that in mind, the old Colombo Racecourse,
whose buildings were originally scheduled for demolition, are presently
undergoing a similar renovation. The pavilions will be conserved and converted
to suit new activities, with the area with road frontage being converted to an
upmarket shopping complex. The ground itself will be converted to an
international standard rugby ground. A third project of a similar nature is the
conversion of the old St. John's Fish Market, which was relocated to Paliyagoda,
to a Bullion Exchange. Many more old buildings with a lot of architectural
features around the Fort area have been renovated and reutilised for commercial
purposes.
When undertaking all the development programmes discussed
earlier, the Government is taking particular care to improve the greenery of the
city and the vitality of its public spaces. Having enough public spaces for
people to relax and enjoy themselves in is very important, and the creation of
more quality public open spaces is presently underway. The development of the
Independence Square area is a good example: this public space which commemorated
Sri Lanka's independence from British rule in 1948, was not properly configured
for public access and use for many years. Under the recent programme to uplift
it, the walls that obstructed it in various places were demolished, and walkways
and cycle paths were created for the use of people. The areas around
Independence Square for people to relax and interact with each other were
improved. Similar developments have taken place around Beira Lake near Nawam
Mawatha and around the Diyawanna Oya in Battaramulla. More such developments are
coming up in Thalawathugoda, near Water's Edge, in Rampalawatta and other areas.
Similar developments must also be made in the North of Colombo, where more and
more congested areas are.
The spaces being developed will not only be accessible to the
general public, they will also be clearly visible to everyone in the city. It is
only through this visibility that the true benefit of such spaces will be felt.
Colombo is a very green city, but unfortunately most of the greenery had been
shut off from public view through the erection of high walls and fences due to
the conflict over the years. Not only was the greenery obscured, the beautiful
architecture of many of the city's buildings was also hidden behind these walls.
People traveling through the city were unable to see its beauty; instead, they
only saw congested city spaces surrounded by high walls. That had a definite
impact on the sense of freedom felt by the general public. With many of these
walls being demolished, Colombo is now a much more pleasant city to live in.
What we have accomplished so far is only a start. Much more remains to be done.
The preservation of waterfront views is another important thing
to consider. For too long, hotels and commercial developments near waterfronts
and the seafront have obscured them from public view. The view of the waterfront
should not be something exclusive to hotel guests and people working in
commercial buildings adjacent to waterfronts; they should be open for the
general public to see and appreciate. A further initiative that should be
implemented in future is the removal of the large billboards that have
mushroomed all over the urban areas. By adopting a proper policy for billboard
advertising, it will be possible to better highlight the natural beauty of our
city spaces.
Through the measures just discussed, the Government hopes that
Colombo will be transformed into a world-class city that can be the centrepiece
of Sri Lanka's economic revival. By upgrading commercial, residential and public
facilities in the city to a very high quality, the city will not only become an
easier one to live in, but will also become a lot more attractive from the point
of view of international investment. With its close proximity to the
international airport, an expanded and upgraded port, and much improved land
communication infrastructure including an Outer Circular Road and Expressways to
other large cities, Colombo will become a true commercial and economic hub. This
is an essential prerequisite for fast-tracking our economic development.
At the same time, the Government has taken steps to develop
cities and towns in the rest of the country. Urban development programmes have
been undertaken in all parts of Sri Lanka. A number of regional development
programmes have already produced impressive results. Even before the end of the
war, a great deal of work was done in the Eastern province to upgrade
infrastructure and create higher quality facilities. A similar programme was
enacted in the North soon after the dawn of peace. The amount of work that has
been done in a short span of time is quite laudable. The on-going development of
towns such as Jaffna, Kilinochchi and Mankulam will result in the people of
those areas gaining access to a much higher quality of urban life.
A large number of small and medium mini towns are scheduled to
be developed from each District during this year. These include towns such as
Imaduwa and Akuressa in Galle, Urubokka in Matara, Eheliyagoda in Ratnapura,
Narammala and Panduwasnuwara in Kurunegala, Dankotuwa and Naththandiya in
Puttalam, as well as Mannar, Haputale and Diyatalawa. These are towns that have
long been neglected, and their infrastructure and public spaces will be
significantly revamped. This will create a much-improved living environment in
these town areas. An example of a very successful recent project of this nature
has been the upgrading of Matara, which is being rapidly developed. Another is
Nuwara Eliya; particularly in the areas surrounding Lake Gregory, the
transformation that has been achieved is quite remarkable.
As a country emerging from the shadow of terrorism into a
bright, prosperous future, Sri Lanka has many challenges to face and many
opportunities to exploit. I hope that the officials and urban specialists of our
country can learn a lot from the experts and participants from other nations
present at this Knowledge Platform. Perhaps these other participants can also
learn something from the Sri Lankan experiences regarding urban development. The
sharing of information and knowledge amongst experts from various countries is
extremely important, and I would like to take this opportunity to congratulate
and thank the World Bank for taking this initiative, and for hosting this
Platform in Colombo. In concluding, let me wish all of you a very pleasant,
productive and enjoyable stay in our beautiful country.
Thank you.
Let's defend and protect our beloved mother sri lanka from demised ruthless LTTE and its sympathizers! Wherever you live on this planet this is your Paramount Duty,remember today we breathe a sigh of relief and Ruthless LTTE terrorism which engulfed the entire nation for more than 30 years was wiped out by our gallant troops.Fallen war heroes,disabled war heroes and those who currently serve the nation always live in our hearts.
Wednesday, March 21, 2012
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
http://www.dailynews.lk/2012/03/21/fea03.asp
Channel 4 - a review
Indi SAMARAJIVA
It's a long video, so my commentary is long. I've
tried to break it up. It's loosely chronological. The start of Killing Fields 2
is about Killing Fields 1 and how awesome it was and how many international
bodies and governments it influenced. There is no talk about how it influenced
or improved Sri Lanka, because it didn't. Ignoring how thousands of civilians
got someplace they didn't live.
The major error they make is saying that government forces drove the LTTE
Tigers and hundreds of thousands of civilians into an ever-smaller area. That
isn't true. The LTTE herded those people at gunpoint, and they used these people
as a human shield to avert general threat in front of them. The strategy was to
provoke international response based on sympathy and terror to preserve a
terrorist group. This is the strategy that Channel 4 has unwittingly become a
part of. Even dead, Prabhakaran is playing.
Without this context, of course, the Sri Lankan government looks terrible,
firing on innocent civilians. Yet it is vital to remember that the LTTE set this
up as a ploy to achieve its strategic objective of continuing the war - a far
worse fate. Based on this omission alone, I think the Channel 4 video is deeply
compromised.
Helpless victims
These are scenes that the LTTE cynically set up for international
consumption, and Channel 4 is eating it up. Making pointing at photographs look
more serious than it is.
Then there is the magic reliance on forensic pathologists to look at
photographs and tell you what they see. In all, there are so far no voices of
people from Sri Lanka (even saying this happened to me, which I have heard),
brown people are either shown as monolithic bad guys or helpless victims, and it
is all about the white man's burden, ie, 'the international community failed
them'.
Kernels of truth
A soldier carrying an elderly Tamil woman during the
conflict.File photo
Anyways, these are Channel 4's indictments.
* Shelling of a UN compound within the no-fire zone
* Denial of food and medicine
* I somehow missed the third one
* The killing of Prabha's 12 year old son
Again, all of these things happen during war, which is why war is horrible.
In the case of shelling, the LTTE promptly moved into any designated zone to mix
with civilians and fire from there. That was their strategy since Kilinochchi
fell. Food and medicine also had to generally go through the LTTE, who would
take if for their cadres and dole out as they pleased. That said, the government
did downplay the number of civilians in there, particularly Mahinda. But that's
not even the issue here. The issue is that these are all situations that the
LTTE set up. Thus the choice wasn't do or not do, it was either do and end the
war, or not do and let the terrorist force get away with it and continue to
wreck havoc for God knows how many more years, or decades. That was the brutal
calculus which the myopic video never addresses - yet it was the decision most
vital to the people of this island.
I still think these allegations are serious and bear discussion, within
context. They just don't lead to the clear indictment that Channel 4 presumes.
At one point Jon Snow simply says it wasn't a hostage operation, but they
never question why people were simply shuffled around a war zone without being
allowed out. Because it was the LTTE not allowing them out, and there is
evidence of them literally herding people at gunpoint. I've spoken to people who
were there at the final moments and they couldn't leave. It ended when they
crossed to the government side, which is what the LTTE prevented. If there was
international pressure at that point it should have been on the LTTE to let
people out, but instead they gerrymandered the emotionomics to turn scrutiny in
the opposite direction.
White man's burden
Throughout the video Channel 4 uses austere announcement and words like
'analyze' and 'evidence' to describe video they got from uncited sources and
people sitting around and looking at photographs or giving opinions from abroad.
It's driven by agenda, not actual facts and analysis, and certainly not context.
They go for a few cases and emotional impact, but it's not the reality. It's
just war porn, staged by the LTTE and distributed by Channel 4 with foreign
announcers. They use a lot of cinematic tricks like filming documents and
computer screens to cover up for the fact that they talk to no one in or even
from Sri Lanka. It's all second-hand data and third-hand analysis when there are
people on the ground who actually can talk - even through a difficult government
to do media work through.
Channel 4 uses infographics and voice-over to substitute for actual
journalism, however hard it is to do. It's all UN documents, UN reports, US
cables, TamilNet-style videos, it's innuendo around a distant truth. They even
set up fake desks with rotating fans and video backgrounds to cover up for the
fact that they don't have direct evidence.
The killing of Prabhakaran's young son I think is pretty bad, but in the
video they have an anonymous source saying that his info led to Prabhakaran's
whereabouts. I dunno. Then they get into the legitimacy of how Prabhakaran was
killed, which is a bit like asking about Bin Laden's assassination by the US. I
mean, really?
I think Channel 4 is also wrong to brush over the LLRC report as not being
substantive. I thought it would be eyewash and it wasn't, it actually did
correct a lot of the original lies. That, however, didn't fit into the Channel 4
narrative so they largely leave it out.
Story over history
Throughout it all there's this underlying agenda that this latter phase of
war shouldn't have been fought at all, that the LTTE should have gotten away
with their hostage maneuver, and that - in effect - the war should have gone on.
I disagree, but it's also a shame to wrap this agenda in a humanitarian flag.
That was the deception the LTTE tried to pull, and it's what Channel 4 is
continuing, I think through decent if arrogant intentions.
The problem with Channel 4 is that they put their agenda before the trial,
and ultimately before the facts. They frame a five-year phase of war as if it
was the war, ignoring the history that brought such a brutal impasse to pass.
They frame the LTTE's human shield as if it happened naturally, which it didn't.
Thus they completely ignore the context of 30 years' of war and terrorism and
the wholesale suffering it caused, making the terrible last phase of the war
still proportional, which is the horrible calculus of a just war. Not whether
suffering happens (it does), but whether it achieves a worthy objective - most
notably ending war.
What about the good of Sri Lanka?
What of the people in the middle, like the people that died in the war and
continue to live here?
So within that context, this documentary is bad. Channel 4 put their
predetermined agenda ahead of inconvenient circumstances and facts, and it does
a disservice to Sri Lanka. They've made a lazy doc, using agenda and 'experts'
to fill in for complexity and actual research. I still think we need to talk
about the subject, but this documentary sucks.
Source: http://www.nation.lk/edition/feature-viewpoint
Channel 4 - a review
Indi SAMARAJIVA
It's a long video, so my commentary is long. I've
tried to break it up. It's loosely chronological. The start of Killing Fields 2
is about Killing Fields 1 and how awesome it was and how many international
bodies and governments it influenced. There is no talk about how it influenced
or improved Sri Lanka, because it didn't. Ignoring how thousands of civilians
got someplace they didn't live.
The major error they make is saying that government forces drove the LTTE
Tigers and hundreds of thousands of civilians into an ever-smaller area. That
isn't true. The LTTE herded those people at gunpoint, and they used these people
as a human shield to avert general threat in front of them. The strategy was to
provoke international response based on sympathy and terror to preserve a
terrorist group. This is the strategy that Channel 4 has unwittingly become a
part of. Even dead, Prabhakaran is playing.
Without this context, of course, the Sri Lankan government looks terrible,
firing on innocent civilians. Yet it is vital to remember that the LTTE set this
up as a ploy to achieve its strategic objective of continuing the war - a far
worse fate. Based on this omission alone, I think the Channel 4 video is deeply
compromised.
Helpless victims
These are scenes that the LTTE cynically set up for international
consumption, and Channel 4 is eating it up. Making pointing at photographs look
more serious than it is.
Then there is the magic reliance on forensic pathologists to look at
photographs and tell you what they see. In all, there are so far no voices of
people from Sri Lanka (even saying this happened to me, which I have heard),
brown people are either shown as monolithic bad guys or helpless victims, and it
is all about the white man's burden, ie, 'the international community failed
them'.
Kernels of truth
A soldier carrying an elderly Tamil woman during the
conflict.File photo
Anyways, these are Channel 4's indictments.
* Shelling of a UN compound within the no-fire zone
* Denial of food and medicine
* I somehow missed the third one
* The killing of Prabha's 12 year old son
Again, all of these things happen during war, which is why war is horrible.
In the case of shelling, the LTTE promptly moved into any designated zone to mix
with civilians and fire from there. That was their strategy since Kilinochchi
fell. Food and medicine also had to generally go through the LTTE, who would
take if for their cadres and dole out as they pleased. That said, the government
did downplay the number of civilians in there, particularly Mahinda. But that's
not even the issue here. The issue is that these are all situations that the
LTTE set up. Thus the choice wasn't do or not do, it was either do and end the
war, or not do and let the terrorist force get away with it and continue to
wreck havoc for God knows how many more years, or decades. That was the brutal
calculus which the myopic video never addresses - yet it was the decision most
vital to the people of this island.
I still think these allegations are serious and bear discussion, within
context. They just don't lead to the clear indictment that Channel 4 presumes.
At one point Jon Snow simply says it wasn't a hostage operation, but they
never question why people were simply shuffled around a war zone without being
allowed out. Because it was the LTTE not allowing them out, and there is
evidence of them literally herding people at gunpoint. I've spoken to people who
were there at the final moments and they couldn't leave. It ended when they
crossed to the government side, which is what the LTTE prevented. If there was
international pressure at that point it should have been on the LTTE to let
people out, but instead they gerrymandered the emotionomics to turn scrutiny in
the opposite direction.
White man's burden
Throughout the video Channel 4 uses austere announcement and words like
'analyze' and 'evidence' to describe video they got from uncited sources and
people sitting around and looking at photographs or giving opinions from abroad.
It's driven by agenda, not actual facts and analysis, and certainly not context.
They go for a few cases and emotional impact, but it's not the reality. It's
just war porn, staged by the LTTE and distributed by Channel 4 with foreign
announcers. They use a lot of cinematic tricks like filming documents and
computer screens to cover up for the fact that they talk to no one in or even
from Sri Lanka. It's all second-hand data and third-hand analysis when there are
people on the ground who actually can talk - even through a difficult government
to do media work through.
Channel 4 uses infographics and voice-over to substitute for actual
journalism, however hard it is to do. It's all UN documents, UN reports, US
cables, TamilNet-style videos, it's innuendo around a distant truth. They even
set up fake desks with rotating fans and video backgrounds to cover up for the
fact that they don't have direct evidence.
The killing of Prabhakaran's young son I think is pretty bad, but in the
video they have an anonymous source saying that his info led to Prabhakaran's
whereabouts. I dunno. Then they get into the legitimacy of how Prabhakaran was
killed, which is a bit like asking about Bin Laden's assassination by the US. I
mean, really?
I think Channel 4 is also wrong to brush over the LLRC report as not being
substantive. I thought it would be eyewash and it wasn't, it actually did
correct a lot of the original lies. That, however, didn't fit into the Channel 4
narrative so they largely leave it out.
Story over history
Throughout it all there's this underlying agenda that this latter phase of
war shouldn't have been fought at all, that the LTTE should have gotten away
with their hostage maneuver, and that - in effect - the war should have gone on.
I disagree, but it's also a shame to wrap this agenda in a humanitarian flag.
That was the deception the LTTE tried to pull, and it's what Channel 4 is
continuing, I think through decent if arrogant intentions.
The problem with Channel 4 is that they put their agenda before the trial,
and ultimately before the facts. They frame a five-year phase of war as if it
was the war, ignoring the history that brought such a brutal impasse to pass.
They frame the LTTE's human shield as if it happened naturally, which it didn't.
Thus they completely ignore the context of 30 years' of war and terrorism and
the wholesale suffering it caused, making the terrible last phase of the war
still proportional, which is the horrible calculus of a just war. Not whether
suffering happens (it does), but whether it achieves a worthy objective - most
notably ending war.
What about the good of Sri Lanka?
What of the people in the middle, like the people that died in the war and
continue to live here?
So within that context, this documentary is bad. Channel 4 put their
predetermined agenda ahead of inconvenient circumstances and facts, and it does
a disservice to Sri Lanka. They've made a lazy doc, using agenda and 'experts'
to fill in for complexity and actual research. I still think we need to talk
about the subject, but this documentary sucks.
Source: http://www.nation.lk/edition/feature-viewpoint
http://www.dailynews.lk/2012/03/21/news01.asp
Former AG Mohan Peiris says :
SL can face vote with confidence
‘India’s position to be taken holistically’ :
Chamikara Weerasinghe
A key member of the Sri Lankan delegation to the UNHRC sessions and former
Attorney General Mohan Peiris yesterday told the Daily News from Geneva that the
resolution could be put to the vote today, tomorrow or even on Friday(23). “ We
have every confidence that India will act in favour of Sri Lanka because it was
with India’s support that Sri Lanka has carried out most of its reconciliation
work,” he said.
“Besides there is no justification for what the US is doing since the Sri
Lankan government has done everything to implement recommendations in the
Lessons Learnt and Reconciliation Report,” he explained. “What more can they ask
when the government has released over 10,000 LTTE cadres who had been arrested
during the last phase of the war and before, after they have been rehabilitated.
‘Thousands of internally displaced Tamils have been resettled in the North
and East as part of the government’;s reconciliation programme,” he said.
He added, “ India has played a vital role in these programmes. Indian helped
Sri Lanka to build 22,000 houses for the displaced under a programme by the
government to construct 45,000 housing units for them, “ Peiris pointed out. “
It is no secret to the international community that the government has committed
Rs 310 billion for the development of infrastructure in the Northern province of
which Rs 210 billion has been used to provide them with water, electricity,
sanitation and other facilities,” he said.
Sri Lankan delegation has explained its work toward national reconciliation
in detail at the Council, he added.
On being asked on the stance by Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh that
Indian will take a last minute decision whether to take action in favour of Sri
Lanka or not,when the full resolution is surfaced by the US, Peiris said ,
“India’s position had to be be taken holistically and we have every confidence
about India’s support as our neighbour and friend.”
Asked how they take the criticism levelled by various NGOs from Sri Lanka in
sideline events, he said these criticisms had no significant bearing because
this is what they have been saying over the years even after so much work has
been done by the the government to address those problems they usually talk
about even in Sri Lanka.
Former AG Mohan Peiris says :
SL can face vote with confidence
‘India’s position to be taken holistically’ :
Chamikara Weerasinghe
A key member of the Sri Lankan delegation to the UNHRC sessions and former
Attorney General Mohan Peiris yesterday told the Daily News from Geneva that the
resolution could be put to the vote today, tomorrow or even on Friday(23). “ We
have every confidence that India will act in favour of Sri Lanka because it was
with India’s support that Sri Lanka has carried out most of its reconciliation
work,” he said.
“Besides there is no justification for what the US is doing since the Sri
Lankan government has done everything to implement recommendations in the
Lessons Learnt and Reconciliation Report,” he explained. “What more can they ask
when the government has released over 10,000 LTTE cadres who had been arrested
during the last phase of the war and before, after they have been rehabilitated.
‘Thousands of internally displaced Tamils have been resettled in the North
and East as part of the government’;s reconciliation programme,” he said.
He added, “ India has played a vital role in these programmes. Indian helped
Sri Lanka to build 22,000 houses for the displaced under a programme by the
government to construct 45,000 housing units for them, “ Peiris pointed out. “
It is no secret to the international community that the government has committed
Rs 310 billion for the development of infrastructure in the Northern province of
which Rs 210 billion has been used to provide them with water, electricity,
sanitation and other facilities,” he said.
Sri Lankan delegation has explained its work toward national reconciliation
in detail at the Council, he added.
On being asked on the stance by Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh that
Indian will take a last minute decision whether to take action in favour of Sri
Lanka or not,when the full resolution is surfaced by the US, Peiris said ,
“India’s position had to be be taken holistically and we have every confidence
about India’s support as our neighbour and friend.”
Asked how they take the criticism levelled by various NGOs from Sri Lanka in
sideline events, he said these criticisms had no significant bearing because
this is what they have been saying over the years even after so much work has
been done by the the government to address those problems they usually talk
about even in Sri Lanka.
Monday, March 19, 2012
http://www.defence.lk/new.asp?fname=Jaffna_Bishop_Praises_Secretary_Defence_20120312_02
Jaffna Bishop praises Secretary Defence for humanitarian assistance
Bishop of Jaffna Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas Savundaranayagam in a
letter written to Secretary Defence Mr. Gotabaya Rajapaksa, praised the timely
action, facilitating vacation of Naval personnel from houses at Mandaithivu.
"The people are very grateful to you for returning their houses
after 22 years", Bishop Savundaranayagam had further stated.
Mandaithivu is a small island and located in 6km distance
south-west of the Jaffna town. There were more than 300 families living and the
islanders were displaced in 1990 due to indiscriminate shelling by LTTE
terrorists.
Most of the families went to Wanni area and other parts of the
Jaffna peninsula. During this period almost all houses were damaged and their
main livelihood-fishing was gravely affected due to intermittent sea borne
attacks by LTTE sea tigers. The coastal areas were declared as High Security
Zone and Sri Lankan Naval Personnel were deployed to tighten security in the
area.
Full text of the letter written by Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas
Savundaranayagam on 23rd Feb, 2012.
Jaffna Bishop praises Secretary Defence for humanitarian assistance
Bishop of Jaffna Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas Savundaranayagam in a
letter written to Secretary Defence Mr. Gotabaya Rajapaksa, praised the timely
action, facilitating vacation of Naval personnel from houses at Mandaithivu.
"The people are very grateful to you for returning their houses
after 22 years", Bishop Savundaranayagam had further stated.
Mandaithivu is a small island and located in 6km distance
south-west of the Jaffna town. There were more than 300 families living and the
islanders were displaced in 1990 due to indiscriminate shelling by LTTE
terrorists.
Most of the families went to Wanni area and other parts of the
Jaffna peninsula. During this period almost all houses were damaged and their
main livelihood-fishing was gravely affected due to intermittent sea borne
attacks by LTTE sea tigers. The coastal areas were declared as High Security
Zone and Sri Lankan Naval Personnel were deployed to tighten security in the
area.
Full text of the letter written by Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas
Savundaranayagam on 23rd Feb, 2012.
http://www.sundayobserver.lk/2012/03/18/fea01.asp
Side shows in GenevA:
NGO activists’ true intentions exposed
By Ranga CHANDRARATHNE
At a ‘side event’ organised by the US-based Human Rights Watch (HRW),
Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu, Sunila Abeysekara and Nimalka Fernando, Sri Lankan NGO
activists, raised a number of issues pertaining to the human rights situation in
Sri Lanka and the issue of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution. The side
event was held against the backdrop of the 19th sessions of the United Nations
Human Rights Council (UNHRC) in Geneva.
In an exclusive interview with the Sunday Observer, Prof. Rajiva Wijesinha
expresses his views on the issues raised by the NGO activists in Geneva.
Question: Among other things, the issue of the 18th Amendment to the
Constitution which empowers the incumbent President to contest for the next
Presidential election was criticised. Apparently the 18th Amendment to the
Constitution has nothing to do with the human rights situation in Sri Lanka. How
does it suddenly become a human rights issue? And what are the specific
provisions introduced in the 18th Amendment to the Constitution?
A: These few NGOs and their backers, financial and emotional, have a
particular view of Sri Lanka which is at odds with the democratic dispensation
currently prevalent in the country. Amongst their bugbears is the 18th
Amendment, which did away with the 17th Amendment they thought sacrosanct.
Unfortunately, they would not accept that the 17th Amendment was
fundamentally flawed, and required revision, as became clear when their present
heroine, the then President Chandrika Kumaratunga refused to make an appointment
under that Amendment.
The new Amendment goes back to allowing the President the choice as to whom
to appoint, but subject to receiving the comments of a multi-stakeholder
committee.
The second part of the 18th Amendment is the removal of term limits, which is
sometimes a worry for practical reasons, but I think in Sri Lanka the practical
reasons suggest this has its advantages, given the strength of what one calls
the lame duck syndrome. This would even have been worse now, given the efforts
of some individuals in some countries to promote regime change, which of course
these particular individuals would relish.
Undermining democracy
Q: Executive Director of the Centre for Policy Alternatives (CPA) in
Colombo, Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu has berated President Mahinda Rajapaksa’s
administration, accusing it of ‘undermining democracy’ and continuing what he
calls a ‘culture of impunity’ in ‘post-war Sri Lanka’. What is obvious, in
analysing the number of allegations is that Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu’s
accusations seem to be broad and general and not specific and insubstantial
under some pet phrases such as ‘undermining democracy’ and ‘culture of
impunity’. What are your comments?
A: That is a recurring problem, the general nature of allegations and
the assumption that the government at the highest echelons is always
responsible. I have often said that, if so-called human rights defenders
concentrate on particular cases and, without drawing conclusions, only ask for
efficient and swift investigations, they would do better. This is how I managed,
in 2008, when there was a spate of abductions in the East, to get the police to
investigate thoroughly, and they found the gangs responsible.
Unfortunately, statements such as those made by these activists are designed
to vilify politicians and the police, who are either intimidated or resentful.
Similarly, when three years ago I asked for more support for police training,
to improve their investigation and interrogation capacities, as well as language
capacity, there was no take up, whereas now things are better, the British for
instance having under the new High Commissioner, abandoned their standoffish
approach and supporting such training.
Post-conflict context
Q: A principal allegation that Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu raised at
the sideline meeting was that those in power “depend on the military to take
care of anti-government protests and even to sell vegetables”. However, it is
not strange that the military is being deployed in construction work and in the
re-building effort particularly in the post-conflict context in other countries.
Against such a context, how do you perceive such allegations?
A: Military involvement in kick- starting businesses is a good thing,
though as I have stated, it should move towards partnerships and training, with
the aim being to allow vulnerable groups to stand on their own feet as soon as
possible. The same goes for construction, and my work in entrepreneurship
training for ex-cadre suggests partnerships there, with training programs, could
be invaluable.
With regard to anti-government protests, dealing with these is a job for the
police, but sometimes the military is needed and this may be better in the
current context where there is deliberate provocation and the police, which have
not had such disciplined training, tend to react more aggressively. Ultimately,
of course, we need to strengthen our police to deal with such situations as
calmly as possible.
Jaffna Bishop praises Defence Secretary for humanitarian assistance
Bishop of Jaffna Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas
Savundaranayagam, in a letter written to Secretary Defence Gotabaya Rajapaksa,
praised the timely action, facilitating the vacation of Naval personnel from
houses at Mandaithivu.
"The people are very grateful to you for returning their houses
after 22 years", Bishop Savundaranayagam had further stated.
Mandaithivu is a small island located six kilometres south-west
of the Jaffna town. There were more than 300 families living there and the
islanders were displaced in 1990 due to indiscriminate shelling by LTTE
terrorists.
Most of the families moved to the Vanni area and other parts of
the Jaffna peninsula. During this period almost all houses got damaged and their
main livelihood, fishing, was gravely affected due to intermittent sea-borne
attacks by LTTE sea tigers. The coastal areas were declared High Security Zones
and Sri Lankan Naval personnel were deployed to tighten security in the area.
Q: One could interpret such allegations and charges against the
Government and the misinterpretation of the Army’s rebuilding effort as part of
a major project aimed at tarnishing the Government’s image at international
level and clamping down war crime charges against the Government. In this
context, how do you analyse such claims by NGO activists and their honesty in
raising such allegations against the Government?
Human rights
A: I don’t believe that the promotion of human rights is their main
agenda, but I think we need to be more thorough in laying down guidelines for
operation and transparency, to get over other motives. As I have said before,
the Government is incompetent at checking on such matters, perhaps because it
started by assuming good faith, which is I think a justifiable assumption with
regard to most NGOs. But some have other agendas, and instead of investigating
these, and their sources of funding, we overreact to all.
However, I think the recent Indian experience, when they found another agenda
behind what seemed home-grown protests against nuclear power plants, suggests
how difficult it is, because previously I used to think India was more competent
than us at such monitoring. I think they are, but much more is needed.
Q: At the meeting, Sri Lankan-based NGO activists also raised the
issue of setting up new High Security Zones in the North and the East despite
the LTTE’s terrorism ending three years ago. What is the current position with
regard to maintain and dismantling of High Security Zones?
A: The Government is trying to remove these as far as possible. While
not compromising on security requirements, I believe we must minimise the use of
private property and restore whatever we can, and sometimes individuals are
careless in making claims that may deprive a lot of people. This happened in
Mullaitivu, but after further consideration the amount of land claimed was
reduced.
I think the Government must be careful to make sure that inconvenience is
minimal, and where it is unavoidable, there should be adequate compensation,
with the possibility of judicial review if people feel aggrieved.
The Liberal Party has always believed that private property should be a
right, but this does not mean that the Government should not have the right to
acquire such for national purposes, provided the procedures to be followed are
clearly laid down and justifiable.
High Security Zones
Q: Is there a truth in the claim of occupying lands belonging to the
Tamil community on the pretext of setting up new High Security Zones?
A: I don’t think that is correct at all, because the need for security
is not a pretext. But, as mentioned, there should be transparency in such
transactions, and also sensitivity.
Q: Alleging that a body of an unidentified person set ablaze in
Colombo 5 where Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu lives, he has raised accountability
issues. Saravanamuttu alleged that no one raised the issue and blamed the
Government for ‘the absence of rule of law and over dependence on the military’.
A: I was informed about that body previously too, by someone who
claimed it was a person who had been abducted.
I have since been told that this was someone of unsound mind. Unfortunately,
Dr Saravanamuttu seems to want to clutch at any straw, or any dead body, to make
his point.
The Government, however, should also have made sure, given where the body was
found, that the facts of the case were made public. And of course it must do
more to prevent abductions, not only because greater police efficiency is vital
for the security of citizens, but also because whatever happens due to private
grudges is laid at the door of the Government.
Q: Given your wide-ranging experience as the former head of the
Government’s Peace Secretariat and a person who studied terrorism, how would you
compare pre-conflict and post-conflict situations with regard to establishing
the rule of law? And how would you interpret the allegation ‘over dependence on
the military’ particularly in the context of the military’s active participation
in the re-building process and the Government’s new development drive?
A: We are obviously in a much better situation, as is apparent for
instance from the claims about abductions and journalists in danger which all
refer to large figures from 2006, without mentioning that most cases were from
2006. I have explained the reasons for those excesses then, when the internecine
warfare between the LTTE and the Tamil groups it had decimated when it had
impunity under the Ceasefire Agreement, or rather in terms of how the CFA was
interpreted, was at its height.
But, as I noted when Human Rights Watch brought out a volume about
disappearances for the March 2008 Human Rights Council Session, with, I think,
96 cases of which only three were from 2007, all the others being from 2006,
such agencies refused to recognise that things have got better.
With regard to military involvement, as I have mentioned, this has been
essential, but of course we should work even more coherently towards
strengthening civil society.
Q:The NGO activists also blamed the Government for carrying out 32
extra-judicial killings and abductions last year and denying the people the
freedom of expression. What are your comments?
A: I do not know how they arrive at these statistics, but I suspect
they put everything at the door of the Government. The Government would do much
better if it expedited police inquiries into many incidents, and the police must
abandon the idea that inquiries involving people close to the Government would
embarrass the Government. Failing to inquire into such cases is a worse
embarrassment. As for people being denied the freedom of expression, that is
complete nonsense, as anyone looking at our newspapers and the electronic media
would realise.
Side shows in GenevA:
NGO activists’ true intentions exposed
By Ranga CHANDRARATHNE
At a ‘side event’ organised by the US-based Human Rights Watch (HRW),
Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu, Sunila Abeysekara and Nimalka Fernando, Sri Lankan NGO
activists, raised a number of issues pertaining to the human rights situation in
Sri Lanka and the issue of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution. The side
event was held against the backdrop of the 19th sessions of the United Nations
Human Rights Council (UNHRC) in Geneva.
In an exclusive interview with the Sunday Observer, Prof. Rajiva Wijesinha
expresses his views on the issues raised by the NGO activists in Geneva.
Question: Among other things, the issue of the 18th Amendment to the
Constitution which empowers the incumbent President to contest for the next
Presidential election was criticised. Apparently the 18th Amendment to the
Constitution has nothing to do with the human rights situation in Sri Lanka. How
does it suddenly become a human rights issue? And what are the specific
provisions introduced in the 18th Amendment to the Constitution?
A: These few NGOs and their backers, financial and emotional, have a
particular view of Sri Lanka which is at odds with the democratic dispensation
currently prevalent in the country. Amongst their bugbears is the 18th
Amendment, which did away with the 17th Amendment they thought sacrosanct.
Unfortunately, they would not accept that the 17th Amendment was
fundamentally flawed, and required revision, as became clear when their present
heroine, the then President Chandrika Kumaratunga refused to make an appointment
under that Amendment.
The new Amendment goes back to allowing the President the choice as to whom
to appoint, but subject to receiving the comments of a multi-stakeholder
committee.
The second part of the 18th Amendment is the removal of term limits, which is
sometimes a worry for practical reasons, but I think in Sri Lanka the practical
reasons suggest this has its advantages, given the strength of what one calls
the lame duck syndrome. This would even have been worse now, given the efforts
of some individuals in some countries to promote regime change, which of course
these particular individuals would relish.
Undermining democracy
Q: Executive Director of the Centre for Policy Alternatives (CPA) in
Colombo, Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu has berated President Mahinda Rajapaksa’s
administration, accusing it of ‘undermining democracy’ and continuing what he
calls a ‘culture of impunity’ in ‘post-war Sri Lanka’. What is obvious, in
analysing the number of allegations is that Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu’s
accusations seem to be broad and general and not specific and insubstantial
under some pet phrases such as ‘undermining democracy’ and ‘culture of
impunity’. What are your comments?
A: That is a recurring problem, the general nature of allegations and
the assumption that the government at the highest echelons is always
responsible. I have often said that, if so-called human rights defenders
concentrate on particular cases and, without drawing conclusions, only ask for
efficient and swift investigations, they would do better. This is how I managed,
in 2008, when there was a spate of abductions in the East, to get the police to
investigate thoroughly, and they found the gangs responsible.
Unfortunately, statements such as those made by these activists are designed
to vilify politicians and the police, who are either intimidated or resentful.
Similarly, when three years ago I asked for more support for police training,
to improve their investigation and interrogation capacities, as well as language
capacity, there was no take up, whereas now things are better, the British for
instance having under the new High Commissioner, abandoned their standoffish
approach and supporting such training.
Post-conflict context
Q: A principal allegation that Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu raised at
the sideline meeting was that those in power “depend on the military to take
care of anti-government protests and even to sell vegetables”. However, it is
not strange that the military is being deployed in construction work and in the
re-building effort particularly in the post-conflict context in other countries.
Against such a context, how do you perceive such allegations?
A: Military involvement in kick- starting businesses is a good thing,
though as I have stated, it should move towards partnerships and training, with
the aim being to allow vulnerable groups to stand on their own feet as soon as
possible. The same goes for construction, and my work in entrepreneurship
training for ex-cadre suggests partnerships there, with training programs, could
be invaluable.
With regard to anti-government protests, dealing with these is a job for the
police, but sometimes the military is needed and this may be better in the
current context where there is deliberate provocation and the police, which have
not had such disciplined training, tend to react more aggressively. Ultimately,
of course, we need to strengthen our police to deal with such situations as
calmly as possible.
Jaffna Bishop praises Defence Secretary for humanitarian assistance
Bishop of Jaffna Rt. Rev. Dr. Thomas
Savundaranayagam, in a letter written to Secretary Defence Gotabaya Rajapaksa,
praised the timely action, facilitating the vacation of Naval personnel from
houses at Mandaithivu.
"The people are very grateful to you for returning their houses
after 22 years", Bishop Savundaranayagam had further stated.
Mandaithivu is a small island located six kilometres south-west
of the Jaffna town. There were more than 300 families living there and the
islanders were displaced in 1990 due to indiscriminate shelling by LTTE
terrorists.
Most of the families moved to the Vanni area and other parts of
the Jaffna peninsula. During this period almost all houses got damaged and their
main livelihood, fishing, was gravely affected due to intermittent sea-borne
attacks by LTTE sea tigers. The coastal areas were declared High Security Zones
and Sri Lankan Naval personnel were deployed to tighten security in the area.
Q: One could interpret such allegations and charges against the
Government and the misinterpretation of the Army’s rebuilding effort as part of
a major project aimed at tarnishing the Government’s image at international
level and clamping down war crime charges against the Government. In this
context, how do you analyse such claims by NGO activists and their honesty in
raising such allegations against the Government?
Human rights
A: I don’t believe that the promotion of human rights is their main
agenda, but I think we need to be more thorough in laying down guidelines for
operation and transparency, to get over other motives. As I have said before,
the Government is incompetent at checking on such matters, perhaps because it
started by assuming good faith, which is I think a justifiable assumption with
regard to most NGOs. But some have other agendas, and instead of investigating
these, and their sources of funding, we overreact to all.
However, I think the recent Indian experience, when they found another agenda
behind what seemed home-grown protests against nuclear power plants, suggests
how difficult it is, because previously I used to think India was more competent
than us at such monitoring. I think they are, but much more is needed.
Q: At the meeting, Sri Lankan-based NGO activists also raised the
issue of setting up new High Security Zones in the North and the East despite
the LTTE’s terrorism ending three years ago. What is the current position with
regard to maintain and dismantling of High Security Zones?
A: The Government is trying to remove these as far as possible. While
not compromising on security requirements, I believe we must minimise the use of
private property and restore whatever we can, and sometimes individuals are
careless in making claims that may deprive a lot of people. This happened in
Mullaitivu, but after further consideration the amount of land claimed was
reduced.
I think the Government must be careful to make sure that inconvenience is
minimal, and where it is unavoidable, there should be adequate compensation,
with the possibility of judicial review if people feel aggrieved.
The Liberal Party has always believed that private property should be a
right, but this does not mean that the Government should not have the right to
acquire such for national purposes, provided the procedures to be followed are
clearly laid down and justifiable.
High Security Zones
Q: Is there a truth in the claim of occupying lands belonging to the
Tamil community on the pretext of setting up new High Security Zones?
A: I don’t think that is correct at all, because the need for security
is not a pretext. But, as mentioned, there should be transparency in such
transactions, and also sensitivity.
Q: Alleging that a body of an unidentified person set ablaze in
Colombo 5 where Dr. Pakiasothy Saravanamuttu lives, he has raised accountability
issues. Saravanamuttu alleged that no one raised the issue and blamed the
Government for ‘the absence of rule of law and over dependence on the military’.
A: I was informed about that body previously too, by someone who
claimed it was a person who had been abducted.
I have since been told that this was someone of unsound mind. Unfortunately,
Dr Saravanamuttu seems to want to clutch at any straw, or any dead body, to make
his point.
The Government, however, should also have made sure, given where the body was
found, that the facts of the case were made public. And of course it must do
more to prevent abductions, not only because greater police efficiency is vital
for the security of citizens, but also because whatever happens due to private
grudges is laid at the door of the Government.
Q: Given your wide-ranging experience as the former head of the
Government’s Peace Secretariat and a person who studied terrorism, how would you
compare pre-conflict and post-conflict situations with regard to establishing
the rule of law? And how would you interpret the allegation ‘over dependence on
the military’ particularly in the context of the military’s active participation
in the re-building process and the Government’s new development drive?
A: We are obviously in a much better situation, as is apparent for
instance from the claims about abductions and journalists in danger which all
refer to large figures from 2006, without mentioning that most cases were from
2006. I have explained the reasons for those excesses then, when the internecine
warfare between the LTTE and the Tamil groups it had decimated when it had
impunity under the Ceasefire Agreement, or rather in terms of how the CFA was
interpreted, was at its height.
But, as I noted when Human Rights Watch brought out a volume about
disappearances for the March 2008 Human Rights Council Session, with, I think,
96 cases of which only three were from 2007, all the others being from 2006,
such agencies refused to recognise that things have got better.
With regard to military involvement, as I have mentioned, this has been
essential, but of course we should work even more coherently towards
strengthening civil society.
Q:The NGO activists also blamed the Government for carrying out 32
extra-judicial killings and abductions last year and denying the people the
freedom of expression. What are your comments?
A: I do not know how they arrive at these statistics, but I suspect
they put everything at the door of the Government. The Government would do much
better if it expedited police inquiries into many incidents, and the police must
abandon the idea that inquiries involving people close to the Government would
embarrass the Government. Failing to inquire into such cases is a worse
embarrassment. As for people being denied the freedom of expression, that is
complete nonsense, as anyone looking at our newspapers and the electronic media
would realise.
http://www.dailynews.lk/2012/03/19/news02.asp
Present allegations to LLRC with evidence’
Chamikara WEERASINGHE
‘Channel Four should present the allegations they make against Sri Lanka Army
with evidence to the Lessons Learnt and Reconciliation Commission (LLRC) instead
of dramatizing their old video clips taken from open sources of pro-LTTE
websites’, the Sri Lanka Army yesterday said. “NGO activists,such as, Pakiasothy
Sarawanamuttu, Sunila Abeysekara, Nimalka Fernando and Sunanda Deshapriya from
Sri Lanka, could have done the same, if they had any true interest in Sri
Lanka’s human rights situation”, states the Army.
Sri Lanka Army Spokesman Brigadier Ruwan Wanigasekera said, Channel 4 as a
rule telecast anti - Sri Lankan material under the influence of the pro - LTTE
diaspora. Their new video footage, which is supposed to be a follow up of their
first one, is full of “shocking comments” synchronized on their old collection
of material from open sources.
Asked why Channel 4 would do that against Sri Lanka, the Brigadier said, “ I
do not want to speculate why they do this, but this is their second attempt to
paint a horrible picture against an Army that has removed one of the ruthless
and internationally banned terrorist group.”
“Yet, they may present their allegations to the LLRC with evidence for
rightful action,.”he said. Asked if the Sri Lanka Army would take action upon
such evidence provided by Channel 4, Brig. Wanigasekera said, “the Army had
appointed a Board to act upon the LLRC, to investigate and punish any
perpetrator in accordance with military law.
“Who is leveling charges against whom” does not matter as long as there is
credible evidence against the perpetrators,” he said.
“The surfacing of the renewed version of Channel 4 video has a close bearing
with members of the Tamil diaspora living in European countries who are now
being asked to return to Sri Lanka,” he pointed out.
“These people have not undergone any hardships during the war. Most of them
had sought asylum in European countries by virtue of the war.
“Raising funds under the banner of helping the Tamil public and the LTTE has
been a lucrative trade for them until Sri Lankan Security Forces eradicated the
LTTE,” he explained.
“They are unable to generate funds from foreign agencies as they used to, or
continue to live comfortable lives in Europe without showing valid cause to do
so in these countries. Hence, they have resorted to this option of “Sri Lanka’s
accountability on war crimes’’ to create an “euphoria” which will prolong their
comfortable living standards in the West”, he said.
On being asked to comment on the situation of NGOs that have criticized Sri
Lanka at the United Nations Human Rights Council, Brig. Wanigasekera said, these
NGO activists have been enjoying the democratic rights of Sri Lanka whole
inflicting damage on the country’s peace.
“They are exercising their freedom of speech and right to expression at the
UNHRC as they have been doing so in Sri Lanka”, he added
Present allegations to LLRC with evidence’
Chamikara WEERASINGHE
‘Channel Four should present the allegations they make against Sri Lanka Army
with evidence to the Lessons Learnt and Reconciliation Commission (LLRC) instead
of dramatizing their old video clips taken from open sources of pro-LTTE
websites’, the Sri Lanka Army yesterday said. “NGO activists,such as, Pakiasothy
Sarawanamuttu, Sunila Abeysekara, Nimalka Fernando and Sunanda Deshapriya from
Sri Lanka, could have done the same, if they had any true interest in Sri
Lanka’s human rights situation”, states the Army.
Sri Lanka Army Spokesman Brigadier Ruwan Wanigasekera said, Channel 4 as a
rule telecast anti - Sri Lankan material under the influence of the pro - LTTE
diaspora. Their new video footage, which is supposed to be a follow up of their
first one, is full of “shocking comments” synchronized on their old collection
of material from open sources.
Asked why Channel 4 would do that against Sri Lanka, the Brigadier said, “ I
do not want to speculate why they do this, but this is their second attempt to
paint a horrible picture against an Army that has removed one of the ruthless
and internationally banned terrorist group.”
“Yet, they may present their allegations to the LLRC with evidence for
rightful action,.”he said. Asked if the Sri Lanka Army would take action upon
such evidence provided by Channel 4, Brig. Wanigasekera said, “the Army had
appointed a Board to act upon the LLRC, to investigate and punish any
perpetrator in accordance with military law.
“Who is leveling charges against whom” does not matter as long as there is
credible evidence against the perpetrators,” he said.
“The surfacing of the renewed version of Channel 4 video has a close bearing
with members of the Tamil diaspora living in European countries who are now
being asked to return to Sri Lanka,” he pointed out.
“These people have not undergone any hardships during the war. Most of them
had sought asylum in European countries by virtue of the war.
“Raising funds under the banner of helping the Tamil public and the LTTE has
been a lucrative trade for them until Sri Lankan Security Forces eradicated the
LTTE,” he explained.
“They are unable to generate funds from foreign agencies as they used to, or
continue to live comfortable lives in Europe without showing valid cause to do
so in these countries. Hence, they have resorted to this option of “Sri Lanka’s
accountability on war crimes’’ to create an “euphoria” which will prolong their
comfortable living standards in the West”, he said.
On being asked to comment on the situation of NGOs that have criticized Sri
Lanka at the United Nations Human Rights Council, Brig. Wanigasekera said, these
NGO activists have been enjoying the democratic rights of Sri Lanka whole
inflicting damage on the country’s peace.
“They are exercising their freedom of speech and right to expression at the
UNHRC as they have been doing so in Sri Lanka”, he added
http://www.island.lk/index.php?page_cat=article-details&page=article-details&code_title=47772
SL condemns Norway-LTTE powwow March 18, 2012, 8:43 pmBy Shamindra Ferdinando The government has strongly protested to Norway for having discussions with the Global Tamil Forum (GTF) in the run-up to the forthcoming vote on a resolution moved by the US, targeting Sri Lanka at the current sessions of the United Nations Human Rights Council. Authoritative sources told The Island that Norway had timed the meeting to send a strong signal to those countries who have still not decided to back the US move. Responding to a query, sources said that Sri Lanka’s ambassador in Oslo had pointed out that Norway was continuing to entertain a group that was committed to undermine the sovereignty and territorial integrity of a democratic country, through activities and an ideology of an internationally designated separatist terror organization, which carried out a violent campaign and a programme of ethnic cleansing in Sri Lanka. The GoSL alleged that such meetings would in no way contribute to the ongoing reconciliation efforts in Sri Lanka. "We continue to tell other parliamentarians and officials on the current situation in Sri Lanka, while strongly urging them to disregard the false claims made by those still pursuing a separatist agenda," a senior diplomatic source said. GTF spokesman, Suren Surendiran said that they had the opportunity to meet Environment and International Development Minister Erik Solheim, leader of the Opposition and Conservative Party Leader Ms Erna Solberg, MP and Ms Karin S Woldseth, MP, of the Progress Party, who is a member of the Foreign Affairs and Defence Parliamentary Select Committee. All three meetings took place last Friday. The Europe-based official told The Island that they were pursuing an international war crimes inquiry. Sri Lankan officials described the Norwegian move as one that was obviously hostile towards the GoSL, especially in the wake of joint US-EU action against the country. Geneva-based sources said that the US and the EU had launched a fresh offensive, leading to the vote. "Even those countries supportive of the US-EU effort had been taken aback by the intensity of the campaign," sources said, adding that the Sri Lanka delegation was fighting back. Well informed sources said that two Norwegian Opposition right wing MPs had told the GTF delegation that whatever their grievances, they had to be addressed by the GoSL, hence the need to work within the democratic framework in SL. The Norwegians had pointed out that though they could raise the SL issue in Oslo, the Tamil Diaspora should explore the possibility of reaching an agreement with the GoSL. Sources said that their position had been different from that of Minister Solheim, who expressed his disappointment with the US-led resolution. The one-time Norwegian peace facilitator in Sri Lanka had asserted that the resolution was not strong enough as the US diluted the proposal in a bid to secure the support of those countries, which weren’t supportive of the original draft. Norway is a member of the 47-member UNHRC. Its three-year term comes to an end coming December. The External Affairs Ministry said that Norway seemed obviously divided over its position with regard to the LTTE rump. Sources recalled how the opposition Conservative party had called publicly for the banning of the LTTE in Norway. "The other party that was involved in the discussions, the Progress party, is even more stronger in their views on the LTTE as they called for anyone involved in any terror organization in Norway to be ‘expelled’ from the country." Sources pointed out that Minister Solheim represented the (Socialist Left-SV) which is now struggling on the political front having the support of only 3.7 % in opinion polls, below the minimum 4 % cutoff needed to obtain parliamentary representation. Oslo-based sources said that a section of the Norwegian establishment continued to ignore the conduct of the LTTE, particularly those operations directed at civilians, including Tamils. "The LTTE’s actions are relevant also to the Norwegian people because of how Breivik has learnt from them—i.e. targeting innocent civilians and state property and employees in his skewed thinking of using violent means to achieve ‘ethnic cleansing—much like the LTTE," sources said, adding that Norway appointed a Special Commission to investigate the Oslo massacre. Comparing the domestic commissions appointed by the respective governments—LLRC & the 22 July Commission, sources said that both processes were justifiable democratic actions not to please external elements, but to strengthen the domestic ‘home-grown’ processes. "Just like Norway, Sri Lanka, too, is addressing the spread of hatred by some elements still harboring a misguided ‘mono-ethnic’ agenda, providing security to its people and curbing illegal fund collection and arms/human smuggling networks, in order to strengthen an inclusive and free society to provide equitable economic growth to the people." How will the Norwegians react if some party raised the report on the Oslo massacre at a future UNHRC session, sources queried. Hits: 3699 Send to Friend Comments (0) Write Your CommentThank you for your comment. Your comment will be published shortly after the moderation process.Name *:Comment * d Verification image:Enter Verification Image *:d
SL condemns Norway-LTTE powwow March 18, 2012, 8:43 pmBy Shamindra Ferdinando The government has strongly protested to Norway for having discussions with the Global Tamil Forum (GTF) in the run-up to the forthcoming vote on a resolution moved by the US, targeting Sri Lanka at the current sessions of the United Nations Human Rights Council. Authoritative sources told The Island that Norway had timed the meeting to send a strong signal to those countries who have still not decided to back the US move. Responding to a query, sources said that Sri Lanka’s ambassador in Oslo had pointed out that Norway was continuing to entertain a group that was committed to undermine the sovereignty and territorial integrity of a democratic country, through activities and an ideology of an internationally designated separatist terror organization, which carried out a violent campaign and a programme of ethnic cleansing in Sri Lanka. The GoSL alleged that such meetings would in no way contribute to the ongoing reconciliation efforts in Sri Lanka. "We continue to tell other parliamentarians and officials on the current situation in Sri Lanka, while strongly urging them to disregard the false claims made by those still pursuing a separatist agenda," a senior diplomatic source said. GTF spokesman, Suren Surendiran said that they had the opportunity to meet Environment and International Development Minister Erik Solheim, leader of the Opposition and Conservative Party Leader Ms Erna Solberg, MP and Ms Karin S Woldseth, MP, of the Progress Party, who is a member of the Foreign Affairs and Defence Parliamentary Select Committee. All three meetings took place last Friday. The Europe-based official told The Island that they were pursuing an international war crimes inquiry. Sri Lankan officials described the Norwegian move as one that was obviously hostile towards the GoSL, especially in the wake of joint US-EU action against the country. Geneva-based sources said that the US and the EU had launched a fresh offensive, leading to the vote. "Even those countries supportive of the US-EU effort had been taken aback by the intensity of the campaign," sources said, adding that the Sri Lanka delegation was fighting back. Well informed sources said that two Norwegian Opposition right wing MPs had told the GTF delegation that whatever their grievances, they had to be addressed by the GoSL, hence the need to work within the democratic framework in SL. The Norwegians had pointed out that though they could raise the SL issue in Oslo, the Tamil Diaspora should explore the possibility of reaching an agreement with the GoSL. Sources said that their position had been different from that of Minister Solheim, who expressed his disappointment with the US-led resolution. The one-time Norwegian peace facilitator in Sri Lanka had asserted that the resolution was not strong enough as the US diluted the proposal in a bid to secure the support of those countries, which weren’t supportive of the original draft. Norway is a member of the 47-member UNHRC. Its three-year term comes to an end coming December. The External Affairs Ministry said that Norway seemed obviously divided over its position with regard to the LTTE rump. Sources recalled how the opposition Conservative party had called publicly for the banning of the LTTE in Norway. "The other party that was involved in the discussions, the Progress party, is even more stronger in their views on the LTTE as they called for anyone involved in any terror organization in Norway to be ‘expelled’ from the country." Sources pointed out that Minister Solheim represented the (Socialist Left-SV) which is now struggling on the political front having the support of only 3.7 % in opinion polls, below the minimum 4 % cutoff needed to obtain parliamentary representation. Oslo-based sources said that a section of the Norwegian establishment continued to ignore the conduct of the LTTE, particularly those operations directed at civilians, including Tamils. "The LTTE’s actions are relevant also to the Norwegian people because of how Breivik has learnt from them—i.e. targeting innocent civilians and state property and employees in his skewed thinking of using violent means to achieve ‘ethnic cleansing—much like the LTTE," sources said, adding that Norway appointed a Special Commission to investigate the Oslo massacre. Comparing the domestic commissions appointed by the respective governments—LLRC & the 22 July Commission, sources said that both processes were justifiable democratic actions not to please external elements, but to strengthen the domestic ‘home-grown’ processes. "Just like Norway, Sri Lanka, too, is addressing the spread of hatred by some elements still harboring a misguided ‘mono-ethnic’ agenda, providing security to its people and curbing illegal fund collection and arms/human smuggling networks, in order to strengthen an inclusive and free society to provide equitable economic growth to the people." How will the Norwegians react if some party raised the report on the Oslo massacre at a future UNHRC session, sources queried. Hits: 3699 Send to Friend Comments (0) Write Your CommentThank you for your comment. Your comment will be published shortly after the moderation process.Name *:Comment * d Verification image:Enter Verification Image *:d
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)